How Do You Make Compound Butter for Grilling?

To make compound butter, soften good butter, mash in fresh herbs, garlic, citrus, or spices, then roll it into a log and chill it until firm. A slice melting over a hot steak or ear of corn is one of the easiest ways to make backyard grilling taste like a restaurant meal.

Compound butter sounds fancy, but it is really just butter with friends mixed in. It takes about ten minutes, keeps well in the freezer, and turns a plain grilled chicken breast into something people ask about.

Below, you will find the basic method, a flavor chart with easy ratios, and tips for storing and serving it all summer long.

What Is Compound Butter?

Compound butter is softened butter blended with flavorings, then chilled so you can slice it like a coin. Chefs keep it on hand because it adds fat, salt, and flavor in one quick move, and it melts into a glossy sauce right on top of hot food.

Because the butter is doing most of the work, the quality of the butter matters. Minerva Dairy butter is slow-churned in small batches with 85% butterfat, which gives compound butter a rich, creamy base that holds herbs and spices without turning watery.

How Do You Make Compound Butter Step by Step?

You only need a bowl, a fork or spatula, and a piece of parchment or plastic wrap.

1. Soften the butter

Let the butter sit at room temperature until it gives easily when pressed but is not shiny or melted. Need a shortcut? Our guide on how to soften butter has a few quick tricks.

2. Prep your mix-ins

Chop herbs finely, grate garlic on a microplane, and zest citrus before you juice it. Small, even pieces mix in better and look prettier when you slice the butter.

3. Mash and mix

Add everything to the butter and mash with a fork or fold with a spatula until evenly mixed. Taste a little on a cracker and adjust the salt, heat, or acid.

4. Roll it into a log

Spoon the butter onto parchment in a rough line, fold the paper over, and roll it into a tight log about the width of a quarter stick. Twist the ends like a candy wrapper.

5. Chill until firm

Refrigerate for at least an hour so it slices cleanly. Then cut coins as you need them.

Which Compound Butter Flavors Go With What?

Use these starting ratios for one 8 oz carton of butter, which equals 1 cup. Taste and tweak from there.

Flavor

Mix-ins for 8 oz butter

Best on

Classic steakhouse

2 grated garlic cloves, 2 tbsp chopped parsley, 1 tsp cracked black pepper

Steak, burgers, baked potatoes

Lemon herb

Zest of 1 lemon, 1 tbsp lemon juice, 2 tbsp chopped dill or chives

Fish, shrimp, asparagus

Chili lime

Zest of 2 limes, 1 tsp chili powder, 1/2 tsp smoked paprika, 2 tbsp cilantro

Corn on the cob, chicken

Honey cinnamon

2 tbsp honey, 1 tsp cinnamon, pinch of salt

Grilled peaches, cornbread, toast

Blue cheese chive

1/3 cup crumbled blue cheese, 2 tbsp chopped chives

Steak, burgers

Garden basil

1/4 cup finely chopped basil, 1 grated garlic clove, 2 tbsp grated parmesan

Tomatoes, pasta, grilled bread

Should You Use Salted or Unsalted Butter?

Either works. Sea salt butter is the easy choice for savory compound butters, since the seasoning is already built in. Unsalted butter gives you full control, which helps when your mix-ins are salty, like blue cheese, parmesan, or anchovy.

Short on time? Minerva Dairy Garlic & Herb Butter is already infused with garlic and parsley, so it is basically a compound butter straight out of the carton. Add lemon zest and a pinch of chili flakes and you are done.

Minerva Dairy Garlic Butter Tube

How Do You Use Compound Butter on the Grill?

The trick is timing. Compound butter is a finishing touch, not a cooking fat, so add it at the end.

On steak and chops

Pull the meat off the grill, set a coin of butter on top, and let it melt while the meat rests. The butter mixes with the juices and makes an instant pan sauce on the plate. Try it with our perfect steak recipe.

On vegetables and corn

Toss grilled zucchini, peppers, or potatoes with a spoonful of soft compound butter right before serving. For corn, roll the hot ear right over a slice of butter.

On seafood

Lemon herb butter is made for shrimp and fish. Brush a little melted butter on during the last minute of cooking, then add a fresh slice on top.

On bread

Spread garden basil or garlic butter on thick slices of bread and toast them on the grill grates until golden.

How Do You Store Compound Butter?

Because compound butter includes fresh ingredients like herbs, garlic, and citrus, treat it like a perishable food. Keep it wrapped tightly in the refrigerator, use it soon, and freeze anything you will not get to.

For freezing, slice the log into coins first and freeze them on a parchment-lined plate, then move them to a resealable freezer bag. That way you can grab one or two coins straight from the freezer and drop them onto a hot steak. Label the bag with the flavor and date. Our guide to freezing butter has more tips for keeping the flavor fresh.

What Are the Most Common Compound Butter Mistakes?

Compound butter is hard to mess up, but a few small slips can make it greasy, bland, or hard to slice.

  • Melting the butter. Butter that turns liquid will not hold your mix-ins evenly and sets up grainy. Soft, not shiny, is the goal.
  • Adding too much liquid. A splash of lemon juice or hot sauce is great. A quarter cup will weep out of the log. Lean on zest and dried spices for big flavor without extra moisture.
  • Chopping herbs too coarsely. Big leaves tear when you slice the log. Mince them fine.
  • Skipping the taste test. Butter mutes flavors once it is cold, so season a touch more boldly than you think you need.
  • Adding it too early. Compound butter on a raw steak over high heat just burns. Save it for the finish.

Get those right and every coin you slice will melt into a smooth, flavorful sauce.

Compound Butter Frequently Asked Questions

A few quick answers for your next cookout.

How much compound butter should I use per steak?

One coin about half an inch thick, roughly 1 tablespoon, is plenty for a single steak. Add a second coin for very large cuts.

Can I make compound butter with dried herbs?

Yes. Use about one third as much dried herb as you would fresh, and let the butter sit for an hour so the herbs soften and release their flavor.

Can I make compound butter ahead of a party?

Absolutely. Make it a day or two before, keep it wrapped in the fridge, and slice it just before serving. For longer, freeze the coins.

What is the easiest compound butter for beginners?

Garlic and parsley. Mash two grated garlic cloves and a couple of tablespoons of chopped parsley into one 8 oz carton of softened butter, then roll and chill.

Ready to Butter Up Your Next Cookout?

Great compound butter starts with great butter. Pick up slow-churned Minerva Dairy butter at your local grocer with our Store Locator or shop online through Instacart or Goldbelly for delivery straight to your door.

Browse our products to find your favorite base, from sea salt to unsalted to garlic and herb, then fire up the grill.

Minerva Dairy Butter Sliced on Display

Related Posts

Find Us in Stores Near You