Roll butter is butter shaped into a thick log and wrapped, instead of being cut into sticks, and it is usually sold in larger sizes like a 2 lb roll. It is the same real butter you know, just in a traditional, farm-style format that is great value for bakers and big families.
If you have only ever bought butter in sticks, a roll can look a little intimidating at first. How do you measure a cup? How do you keep it fresh? We get these questions all the time about our 2 lb rolls.
This guide answers them all, with an easy conversion chart, a no-fuss way to slice the roll, storage tips, and our favorite ways to put a whole roll of butter to work.
Where Does Roll Butter Come From?
Long before butter came in neat paper-wrapped sticks, creameries and farm kitchens packed butter by hand into crocks, molds, and logs. The roll is a nod to that old-fashioned way of selling butter by the pound.
Today, roll butter is especially popular in the Midwest and often shows up in stores with names like country roll or Amish-style roll butter. Those names describe the format and style, so if you care about who made it and how, check the label for the creamery and its location.
Minerva Dairy has been making butter since 1894, and our 2 lb rolls are made at our creamery in Minerva, Ohio, in the same small, slow-churned batches as our 8 oz cartons.
Is Roll Butter Different From Stick Butter?
The shape is different, but the butter inside does not have to be. Our 2 lb rolls and 8 oz cartons are both made with 85% butterfat and milk from local, pasture-raised cows.
The roll simply gives you more butter in one package. Many bakers love it because it is a better value per pound for holiday baking, family meals, and anyone who goes through butter quickly. Minerva Dairy rolls come in sea salt and unsalted.
How Do You Measure Roll Butter Without Sticks?
A kitchen scale is the easiest tool. Butter conversions are based on weight, so once you know the weight you need, you can slice exactly that much from the roll. Use this chart as your guide.
Recipe calls for | Tablespoons | Ounces | Grams (approx.) | Stick equivalent |
1/4 cup | 4 | 2 | 57 | 1/2 stick |
1/2 cup | 8 | 4 | 113 | 1 stick |
3/4 cup | 12 | 6 | 170 | 1 1/2 sticks |
1 cup | 16 | 8 | 227 | 2 sticks |
2 cups | 32 | 16 | 454 | 4 sticks |
Whole 2 lb roll | 64 | 32 | 907 | 8 sticks |
No scale? Soften the butter slightly and pack it into dry measuring cups, pressing out air pockets and leveling the top. For more conversion help, see how many sticks of butter make 1 cup.
How Do You Slice a Roll of Butter?
Here is an easy method that makes measuring a breeze for weeks.
1. Start cold
Cold butter slices cleanly. Take the roll straight from the fridge.
2. Weigh and divide
Set the whole roll on a kitchen scale. A 2 lb roll weighs about 32 ounces. Cut it in half, then cut each half in half, giving you four 8 oz portions, each equal to 1 cup.
3. Use a warm knife
Dip a sharp knife in hot water and wipe it dry before each cut for smooth slices.
4. Wrap and label
Wrap each portion tightly and label it with the amount. Keep one in the fridge for this week and freeze the rest.
Need smaller amounts for everyday cooking? Cut one of those 8 oz portions into eight equal slices. Each slice is about 1 ounce, or 2 tablespoons, which is just right for a skillet of eggs, a pan of vegetables, or a few slices of toast.
How Should You Store Roll Butter?
A big roll lasts longer than a single carton, so storage matters.
- Keep it wrapped. Store butter in its packaging or tight wrap so it does not absorb fridge odors.
- Leave out a little. USDA guidance says butter is safe at room temperature, but its flavor can turn rancid after several days, so keep only what you will use in a day or two in the butter dish.
- Freeze extras. Minerva Dairy butter can be frozen for up to 24 months. Place wrapped portions in a resealable freezer bag to protect against freezer burn.
- Watch the best-by date. As the butter in your fridge nears its date, move it to the freezer.
Learn more in our guides on freezing butter and how long butter lasts in the fridge.
What Are the Best Ways to Use a Roll of Butter?
Holiday baking
Cookies, pies, and cakes go through butter fast. A single 2 lb roll covers several batches of cookies plus a pie crust or two.
Pound cake
A classic pound cake uses a full pound of butter. Try our classic Minerva butter pound cake.
Family dinners
Mashed potatoes, roasted vegetables, rolls, and pan sauces all taste better with real butter.
The table
Set a thick slice of sea salt roll butter on a pretty dish for bread and rolls. It looks generous and old-fashioned in the best way.
Is Roll Butter Worth Buying?
If you bake often, cook for a crowd, or simply love butter on everything, a roll is a smart buy. It is also a great choice for the holidays, when recipes call for a cup here and two sticks there. If you only use a little butter each week, 8 oz cartons with two 4 oz quarter sticks may be more convenient, and you can always freeze part of a roll.
A roll also makes a thoughtful gift for the bakers in your life. Tie a ribbon around a 2 lb roll, add a favorite cookie recipe card, and you have a present that will actually get used. Many families also like to keep one sea salt roll for the table and one unsalted roll for baking, so they always have the right butter on hand. Whichever way you use it, a roll means fewer trips to the store and more butter ready when inspiration strikes.
Roll Butter Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers about butter rolls.
How many sticks are in a 2 lb roll of butter?
A 2 lb roll equals about 8 standard sticks, or 4 cups, 64 tablespoons, and roughly 907 grams.
How do I measure 1 cup from a roll of butter?
Weigh out 8 ounces, about 227 grams, on a kitchen scale. That equals 1 cup or 2 sticks.
Can I freeze a roll of butter?
Yes. Minerva Dairy butter can be frozen for up to 24 months. Cut the roll into portions, wrap them well, and place them in a resealable freezer bag.
Is Minerva Dairy roll butter salted or unsalted?
Both. Minerva Dairy 2 lb rolls come in sea salt and unsalted, each with 85% butterfat.
Ready to Butter Up With a 2 lb Roll?
Holiday baking season is the perfect time to try a roll. Find Minerva Dairy 2 lb rolls near you with our Store Locator or shop online through Instacart or Goldbelly for delivery straight to your door.
See all sizes and flavors on our products page.