10 Festive Fall Pie Recipes

There aren’t many things better than a quality pie, especially during fall. With warm and cozy flavors, tons of spices and the warmth that the oven creates, this is the perfect time of year to test your pie baking skills.  

A pie is a timeless, versatile and portable dish that’s sure to be a hit at every potluck and dinner party you attend this season, not to mention that they’ll bring the festive life to the party! We’re sharing our favorite sweet and savory pies to impress everyone in your life this autumn (including yourself!).

So, without further ado, here are our top 10 favorite festive fall pie recipes:

SAVORY

Tomato Pie with Garlic Herb Crust

Most people think of pie filling when they think of pie flavor, but this Tomato Pie with Garlic Herb Crust proves that the crust is just as important as what’s inside it!

Farmhouse Pork & Apple Pie

Pie is one of the most versatile dishes you can possibly find. This pork and apple pie fuses your favorite fall fruit with protein for a delectable dinner, all in one dish! Make it even better with Minerva unsalted butter in the crust!

Handheld Ham & Cheese Pie

Any potlucks on the calendar? These handheld ham & cheese pies are a small, savory, mess-free way to enjoy pie no matter where you’re headed! This recipe calls for an entire stick of butter, so don’t forget to have our unsalted butter on hand before you start cooking!

Turkey & Cranberry Pie

This pie checks all the important Thanksgiving boxes on our list: cranberry sauce, delicious turkey, and a hearty amount of butter (even better when you use Minerva butter!). Use this creative swap on Thanksgiving this year to impress your family, or save it for your leftovers.

Savory Sweet Potato Pie

Loaded with butter, cheese and herbs, this sweet potato pie is a nice spin on one of our favorite fall side dishes: sweet potatoes. Our favorite part? You need butter in the crust and in the filling! 

SWEET

Eggless Chocolate Crème Pie

Chocolate might not be a typical fall flavor, but this eggless creme pie is a welcomed, lighter switch from the typical flavors you’d see around this time of year.

Old Fashioned Paradise Pumpkin Pie

Take your pumpkin pie to the next level with this layered pie recipe – complete with pecans and brown sugar! Try it with this buttery pie crust and Minerva’s unsalted butter for an even better paradise pie.

Cranberry Pie

Bring the feeling of fall into the dining room this season with a cranberry pie that fuses warm flavors with comfort food. The only question is – do you serve it with dinner or dessert? Our vote is dessert, especially if you use the better butter!

Caramel Apple Whoopie Pies

These delicious handheld pies are family friendly, kid-approved and incorporate the best of fall: green apples! 

Sweet Potato Tart

Let’s face it – everyone in America probably has their own sweet potato pie or sweet potato casserole recipe, and a lot of them are similar. Break the mold of boring sweet potato dishes with this delightfully unique take on a pie.

We hope you enjoyed our recipe round up for the tastiest, festive fall pie recipes. For delicious recipes featuring Minerva Dairy’s better butter, head to our Recipes page. Be sure to keep up with our latest creations through our Facebook, Pinterest, or Instagram page and our top tips through our blogs.